| Charles Barnes Men's Basketball - 1958 | Herb
Magee Men's Basketball - 1962-63 |
| Joe Memoli Men's Soccer - 1966 | Bob Ludwig Men's Soccer - 1967 |
| Bob Durham Men's Soccer - 1969-70 | Gordon
Cholmondley Men's Soccer - 1969-71 |
| Carlton Poole Men's Basketball - 1970 | Bruce Shiveley Men's Basketball - 1971-72 |
| Barry Barto Men's Soccer - 1971-72 | Dale Russell Men's Soccer - 1973-76 |
| Elson Seale Men's Soccer - 1974-76 | John Nusum Men's Soccer - 1974-77 |
| Brooks Cryder Men's Soccer - 1975 | Emory Sammons Men's Basketball - 1976-77 |
| Adrian Brooks Men's Soccer - 1976-78 | Dave McWilliams Men's Soccer - 1978 |
| Randy Owens Men's Basketball - 1979 | Peter Alkins Men'sSoccer - 1979 |
| Steve McLean Men's Soccer - 1980-83 | Tom McDonald Men's Soccer - 1980-81 |
| Tim Killeen Men's Soccer - 1981-82 | Bernie Burke Track & Field - 1982 |
| Ken Place Track & Field - 1982-83 | Steve Perillo Men's Soccer - 1983 |
| Ed Weaver Men's Basketball - 1983 | Sean Fryatt Men's Soccer - 1984 |
| Vincene Morris Women's Basketball - 1984-86 | Jill Burkert Women's Basketball - 1985-86 |
| Darren Keith Men's Basketball - 1985-86 | Guy Furfaro Men's Soccer - 1986 |
| Tom
Carroll Track & Field - 1988 | Mornez Rasdell Track & Field - 1988-90 Indoor Track & Field - 1989-90 |
| Steve
Starcevich Men's Soccer - 1988 | Mike Louden Men's Basketball - 1989 |
| David Banks Men's Soccer - 1989 | Randy Stover Men's Basketball - 1990-92 |
| Ian Swift Academic - Cross Country/ Track & Field 1990 | Mike Kerrigan Baseball - 1990 |
| Ira Prince Baseball - 1990 | Darlene
Hildebrand Women's Basketball - 1992 |
| Tammy Greene Women's Basketball - 1991-94 | David Fields Men's Basketball - 1994 |
| Eugene Haith Men's Basketball - 1994 | Diana Trzaska Women's Soccer - 1995 |
| Melissa
DerPilbosian Women's Lacrosse - 1997-98 | Bob File Baseball - 1998 |
| Theresa Carroll Women's Basketball - 2000 | Jim Reeves Men's Basketball - 2002 |
| Kristin Tyler Women's Lacrosse - 2003 | Tara Rowe Women's Lacrosse - 2004 |
| Janet Tarpey Women's Lacrosse - 2004-05 | Samara Speakes Women's Basketball - 2005 |
| Tayron Thomas Men's Basketball - 2005-06 | Christian Burns Men's Basketball - 2007 |
